3 min read

Unpacking the Complexities of Home Sale Taxes: A Case Study


Content provided for general information. Talk to your advisor to learn about recent updates or other rules that may apply to your situation.

The world of real estate and taxation can be a bewildering one, especially when ownership arrangements and personal circumstances intertwine. A scenario recently posed by a concerned individual raises questions about a property that was initially owned jointly but later underwent a change in ownership and occupancy. With the sale of the property in 2022, the primary concern centers around the allocation of the capital gains tax and the reporting of proceeds on the 1099-S form and settlement statement. In this blog post, we will delve into the intricacies of this case, discussing the potential tax implications, the role of the 1099-S form, and the importance of seeking professional advice from a tax advisor.

The Property Purchase

Our case begins in 2010 when the client purchased a house for $100,000. What sets this scenario apart is that the property deed listed the ownership as 50% for the client and 50% for his mother. Such joint ownership is a common arrangement among family members. It allows them to share the responsibilities and benefits associated with homeownership. However, as we will see, it can complicate matters when it comes to selling the property and determining the allocation of capital gains.

Change in Occupancy and Ownership

Fast forward to 2019, and the client decides to move out of the house. Simultaneously, he purchases another property for his own residence. His mother, still owning her 50% share, moves into the house. This change in occupancy and the subsequent removal of the client's name from the property title represent a pivotal moment in this case. The shift in occupancy may lead to the question of whether the property still qualifies as the client's primary residence, which is a critical factor in determining the capital gains tax.

The Sale of the Property

In 2022, the property is sold for $250,000. However, a significant point of concern arises regarding the 1099-S form and settlement statement. These documents only list the client's name and social security number, indicating that the entire sale proceeds were reported under his name. Nevertheless, it is essential to understand that the mother retained a 50% ownership stake in the property, lived in it for more than two years, and presumably qualified for the personal home sale exemption.

Understanding the Tax Implications

To comprehend the potential tax implications in this scenario, it's necessary to break down the key elements:

  1. Capital Gains on the Client's Half: The client is responsible for the capital gains tax on his 50% share of the property's appreciated value. The $150,000 gain from the sale is subject to capital gains tax. The tax rate depends on various factors, including the client's overall income, the length of time the property was held, and any applicable tax exemptions or deductions.
  2. Mother's Personal Home Sale Exemption: Since the mother owned 50% of the property and lived in it for more than two years, she may qualify for the personal home sale exemption. This exemption allows homeowners to exclude up to $250,000 ($500,000 for married couples filing jointly) of the capital gain from the sale of their primary residence.
  3. Proper Allocation of Proceeds: One of the key concerns is the allocation of the sale proceeds. While the 1099-S form and settlement statement list only the client's name, it is crucial to ensure that the mother's share of the sale is correctly reported and accounted for.

Seeking Professional Advice

In a case as complex as this, it is imperative to emphasize the need to consult with a qualified tax advisor. A tax advisor can provide guidance on a variety of issues, including:

  • Determining the tax liability for the client's portion of the sale.
  • Assessing whether the mother qualifies for the personal home sale exemption.
  • Exploring options for properly allocating the sale proceeds between the client and his mother.
  • Ensuring compliance with tax laws and regulations.


The sale of a jointly owned property with changing occupancy and a complex history can create intricate tax scenarios. While it may seem that the mother qualifies for the personal home sale exemption, the proper allocation of proceeds and adherence to tax regulations are critical. Seeking advice from a tax advisor is strongly recommended in such situations. A tax advisor can provide personalized guidance, ensuring that the tax implications are addressed correctly and that the interests of all parties involved are protected. Remember that this blog post serves as an informative overview of the situation, and the specific details and nuances should be discussed with a tax advisor for a comprehensive understanding of the tax implications and responsibilities in this unique case.