3 min read

Navigating Tax Implications When Moving Between States: A Case Study


Content provided for general information. Talk to your advisor to learn about recent updates or other rules that may apply to your situation.

Moving from one state to another can be a significant life change, and it often comes with various financial and administrative tasks to handle. Among these tasks, understanding the tax implications of your move is crucial to ensure compliance and avoid unexpected financial burdens. In this blog post, we will explore a scenario where an individual lived in Connecticut for part of 2022, then moved to New York City, and subsequently encountered issues with their W2 form. We will analyze the potential tax implications and considerations, but please remember that tax matters can be complex, and it is always advisable to consult with a tax advisor for personalized guidance.

Understanding State Residency

One of the primary factors that determine your state tax obligations is your residency status. Residency rules can vary from state to state, and it's essential to determine when your residency began and ended in each state. In this case, the individual lived in Connecticut from April 2022 to September 2023. This means they were considered a resident of Connecticut during this period.

Correcting the W2 Form

The individual mentioned that their W2 was corrected to reflect their updated address, and it now shows no wages earned in Connecticut. However, their initial stay in Connecticut should have generated income in that state, and they would have likely been subject to Connecticut state income taxes for the portion of the year they resided there.

It's advisable to review the corrected W2 carefully and ensure that the wages earned during the period in Connecticut are accurately reported. If they are not, you may need to reach out to your payroll department or your employer to rectify any inaccuracies. It's crucial to have an accurate W2 to file your state and federal taxes correctly.

New York State Tax Obligations

The individual also mentioned earning approximately $40,000 in New York state wages and paying around $2,300 in New York state income taxes. These figures seem correct as they relate to the time they spent working in New York City. New York State has specific tax rates, and if you lived and worked in the state during that time, it's reasonable to have New York State income tax obligations.

New York City Tax Obligations

One of the key points of concern is the individual's admission that they did not pay local taxes to New York City while living and working there. This is a crucial matter because New York City imposes its own income tax in addition to New York State income tax. It's essential to address this issue and rectify the situation to avoid potential penalties and interest on unpaid taxes.

Connecticut State Income Tax

While living in Connecticut, the individual mentioned that they were paying Connecticut State Income Tax (SIT). This is expected since Connecticut imposes state income tax on its residents. However, since they earned wages in New York while residing in Connecticut, they may also have an income tax obligation to New York State. The tax laws in both states can be complex when it comes to credits and deductions, and it is vital to consult with a tax advisor to ensure that you're not overpaying or underpaying state income taxes.

Future Tax Implications

The individual expressed concern about their 2023 taxes, anticipating a refund from Connecticut but potentially owing money to New York City. The exact tax outcomes for future years will depend on various factors, including changes in residency, income sources, and tax laws. To navigate this complex landscape, it is highly advisable to consult with a tax advisor who can help you plan your tax strategy and minimize potential liabilities.


In the case of moving between states and dealing with tax implications, it's crucial to maintain accurate records, address discrepancies on your W2, and understand the tax rules and regulations of each state. The individual in this scenario should work with a tax advisor to resolve the outstanding tax issues, rectify any discrepancies on their W2, and plan for their 2023 taxes accordingly. While this blog post provides general guidance, it is not a substitute for professional advice, and consulting a tax advisor is the best course of action to ensure compliance and financial peace of mind.