8 min read

Roth IRA vs Savings Account: Best Option for College Students

Navigating the maze of financial decisions as a college student can seem daunting, especially when it comes to setting aside money for the future. Understanding the differences and benefits of a Roth Individual Retirement Account (IRA) and a savings account can offer a solid grounding to make informed decisions. Each financial strategy comes with its unique functionalities, advantages and disadvantages, as well as potential for growth over time. As you embark on your financial journey, equipping yourself with this knowledge can be a powerful tool towards building a robust fiscal future.

Understanding Roth IRA and Savings Account

Understanding Roth IRA and Savings Account

A Roth Individual Retirement Account or Roth IRA is a special type of savings account that offers tax-free growth and withdrawal. Unlike traditional IRA, where your contributions are tax-deductible, the money you put into a Roth IRA is after-tax dollars, which means you’ve already paid taxes on it. This provides the key advantage of tax-free growth and withdrawal. In other words, the money you earn from investments in your Roth IRA and the amount you withdraw during your retirement isn’t taxed.

On the other hand, a savings account is a deposit account held at a bank or other financial institution that provides a modest interest rate. Traditionally, it’s used by individuals who want to save money while earning a small return. However, it’s also the most liquid form of investment, meaning people can withdraw their money at any time, which isn’t possible with IRAs without penalties.

Ideal for Whom

A Roth IRA is designed for individuals who believe they will be in the same or a higher tax bracket when they retire. It can be an excellent choice for young wage earners, such as college students who might be at their career’s lowest earning points. This allows them to benefit from years of tax-free growth. It’s important to note that there are some income restrictions for contributing to a Roth IRA.

On the other hand, savings accounts can be used by anyone who wants ready access to their money. College students can utilize savings accounts for their short-term goals or as an emergency fund.

Interest Rates

The interest rate for a Roth IRA depends on the performance of the investments within the account. While the specific rate of return may vary, IRAs typically have a higher potential for returns compared to simple savings accounts due to their longer-term investment outlook.

For savings accounts, the national average interest rate is currently around 0.06%. Depending on your bank and the specific type of savings account, you might get a slightly higher or lower rate. However, the rate is usually lower due to the immediate liquidity provided by these accounts.

Pros and Cons

The biggest advantage of a Roth IRA is it lets your money grow and allows you to withdraw your funds tax-free. Due to the magic of compounding over time, this can lead to considerable profit. Importantly, unlike other retirement savings options, Roth IRAs have no mandatory distribution age.

On the flip side, the Roth IRA comes with income eligibility restrictions and penalties for accessing your earnings before the age of 59.5 years unless you meet some specific criteria.

On the other hand, a savings account delivers modest interest but provides excellent liquidity, useful for unexpected short-term needs. The flexibility, ease in opening and management, and the FDIC insurance coverage up to $250,000 per person, make it an attractive option.

But it’s not all rosy with a savings account – the traditionally abysmal interest rates may trail behind the inflation rate, subtly eroding your money’s buying power over time. Also, watch out for fees if your account balance drops below the bank’s minimum threshold.

Why Consider Roth IRA or Savings Account as a College Student

Starting Early: A Key Component to Financial Success

During the college years, the mere thought of embarking on a career may seem like it’s far in the future and retirement even further. The concept of financial planning at this stage can sound excessive. But starting earlier rather than later in setting a solid financial foundation could prove invaluable in the future. The practical path to laying this groundwork could be either through a Roth IRA or a savings account.

Roth IRA: A Potent Tool for College Students

A Roth IRA or Individual Retirement Account is a retirement savings account that allows your money to grow free of tax. This can be incredibly beneficial since the amount you contribute can multiply over several years due to the power of compounding. You’re essentially earning interest on your interest, which can result in a significant buildup over time. For college students, this is especially advantageous because they have a long timeline to let their money accumulate. In addition, Roth IRA’s flexibility is another perk often highlighted. Unlike other retirement accounts, you can withdraw your contributions (but not your earnings) at any time and for any reason, without incurring penalties.

Traditional Savings Account: A Safe Haven

On the other hand, a traditional savings account is a reliable and low-risk option for college students looking to secure their money. Provided by most banks and credit unions, these accounts accrue interest over time. Although the accumulated interest rates are usually lower than those of a Roth IRA or other investments, the capital is generally safe and easily accessible, making it an excellent choice for students who want to save for short term goals or need an emergency fund.

Which is better? Roth IRA or Savings Account?

In choosing between a Roth IRA or a Savings account, it boils down to your financial goals and circumstances. If you’re looking for a long term saving tool, the Roth IRA might be a superior choice given its tax advantages and the power of compounding. Conversely, if you anticipate needing the money sooner rather than later, maybe for an emergency or major purchase, a savings account provides ready access to your funds.

The Interplay of Roth IRA and Savings Account

However, it’s important to underline that these two financial tools aren’t mutually exclusive. You can strategically use both to your advantage. A Roth IRA can be used as a long-term investment strategy, laying the base for your retirement. Simultaneously, a savings account could address your liquidity needs, facilitating short-term savings and an emergency fund.

It’s important to understand that our college years are not exclusively about achieving scholastically. They are equally a critical period for building financial literacy skills. Adopting financial planning measures early, like focusing on a Roth IRA or a savings account, ensures college students are laying the groundwork for their future financial stability.

Comparing Roth IRA vs Savings Account for College Students

Comprehending the Basics of Roth IRA and Savings Accounts

Roth IRA and savings accounts are two prevalent financial instruments available for students in college to save and multiply their financial resources. A Roth IRA, which stands for Individual Retirement Account, is a form of retirement savings account that promotes long-term saving with benefits such as tax-free growth and tax-free withdrawals during retirement. On the other hand, a conventional savings account is a basic facility provided by all banks where you can deposit money, earn a minimal amount of interest, and have the flexibility to withdraw your money whenever required.


When it comes to flexibility, savings accounts generally rank higher than Roth IRAs. Savings accounts allow you to deposit and withdraw any time you feel like, while Roth IRAs have significant regulations and restrictions on withdrawals, especially if it’s before the age of 59 and a half.

Potential Growth

In terms of potential growth, Roth IRA generally surpasses savings accounts because they invest in financial markets where there’s potential for substantial growth over time. In contrast, savings accounts provide little return due to their notoriously low-interest rates.

Tax Advantages

One of the principal benefits of a Roth IRA is its tax structure. Contributions to Roth IRAs are made with post-tax dollars, which means that while you don’t get a tax break when you deposit your money, your earnings grow tax-free, and in retirement, your withdrawals are also tax-free. On the other hand, savings account interest is taxable as ordinary income.

Withdrawal Penalties

Savings accounts generally don’t have withdrawal penalties, apart from typical bank fees for excessive transactions. However, Roth IRAs impose penalties on withdrawals before age 59.5, except for some qualifying reasons, including education costs. Specifically, withdrawals on earnings (not contributions) before age 59.5 are subject to income tax and a 10% penalty unless it’s for a qualified exception.

Long-term Benefits

Roth IRAs are intended for long-term savings, specifically for retirement. Over several decades, substantial growth can occur, providing significant retirement income. Because of their structure, they may also encourage disciplined savings habits. Meanwhile, savings accounts are more convenient for short-term savings and readily accessible cash, but aren’t suitable for long-term wealth accumulation due to their meager interest rates.

A Brief Overview

Both Roth IRA and savings accounts present different benefits tailored to the specific needs and goals of a student. If a long-term saving plan with the added advantage of market returns and tax benefits appeals to you, a Roth IRA would be your best fit. On the other hand, if you require regular access to your funds and prefer to avoid the limitations and potential penalties associated with a Roth IRA, a savings account would be your optimal choice. Hence, a thorough comprehension of both these account types is vital in making the right financial decision.

How to Choose Between a Roth IRA and Savings Account

Diving Deeper into Roth IRA and Savings Accounts

Roth Individual Retirement Account (Roth IRA) and savings accounts are two popular options for individuals, especially college students, to save, secure, and build their funds. Knowing how they function is the priority towards making an informed decision.

A Roth IRA operates as a dedicated retirement savings account where eligible individuals contribute money after-tax. Any withdrawals made in retirement (post the age of 59½) are generally tax-free. Funds in a Roth IRA are typically invested in avenues like stocks, bonds, or mutual funds, opening room for substantial returns, albeit with an investment risk.

A savings account, conversely, is a deposit account housed at a bank or any other financial institution. While it does offer interest on your deposits, the returns are considerably lower than what you could achieve through investments in stocks or bonds via an IRA.

Risk Tolerance

One of the key differences between a Roth IRA and a savings account lies in the level of risk associated with each. Due to the nature of investments made within a Roth IRA, there is a higher level of risk compared to a savings account, which carries virtually no risk. If you have a higher risk tolerance and are comfortable with the possibility of your investments fluctuating, a Roth IRA could potentially yield higher returns. On the flip side, a savings account provides guaranteed growth, albeit at a slower pace.

Time Horizon

Another important factor to consider when choosing between a Roth IRA and a savings account is your time horizon. Given the potential for higher returns, a Roth IRA is typically better suited for long-term savings goals, such as retirement. The longer you keep your money in a Roth IRA, the more time it has to potentially recover from downturns in the market. In contrast, a savings account might be better for shorter-term financial goals.

Financial Goals

What you aim to accomplish with your money plays a significant role in determining whether a Roth IRA or a savings account would be most beneficial. For a long-term goal like retirement, a Roth IRA would typically be more suitable due to its tax advantages and potential for higher returns. On the other hand, if you’re saving for a short-term goal like a car purchase or vacation, a savings account — with its guaranteed returns and lack of stock market volatility — might be more appropriate.

Income Level and Future Earning Potential

Given the income restrictions on contributing to a Roth IRA, your current income level and projected future income will also play a part in deciding between a Roth IRA and a savings account. If you meet the income criteria for a Roth IRA and have a relatively low income now but anticipate higher income (and possibly a higher tax bracket) in the future, contributing to a Roth IRA could be advantageous as you pay taxes now while your taxable income is low.

Consulting a Financial Advisor

Regardless of your situation, consulting with a financial advisor can provide personalized guidance as you navigate the specifics of your financial landscape. They will help you to evaluate your risk tolerance, understand your income projections, and clearly define your short-term and long-term financial goals, guiding you to make a well-informed decision between a Roth IRA and a savings account.

Each individual’s financial journey and future goals are unique, so choosing between a Roth IRA and a savings account isn’t a one-size-fits-all decision. Therefore, it’s critical to evaluate factors like your risk tolerance, future earning potential, and time horizon when making your choice. Incorporating these considerations can help you build a comprehensive financial strategy that aligns with your long-term aspirations and provides the monetary stability you need. No matter where your financial journey takes you, starting early and making informed decisions can set you on a path towards a secure and prosperous future.