9 min read

QuickBooks vs Gusto: A Comprehensive Comparison


Content provided for general information. Talk to your advisor to learn about recent updates or other rules that may apply to your situation.

Disclosure: I may receive a referral fee if you buy software through the links on each page. However, most apps have free trials, so go ahead and try a few at no risk to you.

In the modern business landscape, the efficiency of financial management tools can either impede or accelerate a company’s growth. Two leading players in this arena, QuickBooks and Gusto, have transformed how businesses handle their financial operations. From easy invoicing to comprehensive payroll services, these platforms offer a myriad of features tailored for different business needs. In this exploration, we will delve deeper into the functionalities, pricing, usability, and user feedback for QuickBooks and Gusto, helping you make an informed decision about which platform best suits your specific business needs.

Overview of QuickBooks and Gusto

Overview: QuickBooks and Gusto

QuickBooks is a comprehensive accounting software developed and marketed by Intuit. The platform was first launched in 1983 with the purpose of offering small and mid-sized businesses an affordable, user-friendly accounting tool. Over time, QuickBooks has evolved to serve over seven million businesses worldwide, providing a full spectrum of financial management features including invoicing, expense tracking, payroll services, and tax preparation.

On the other hand, Gusto, formerly known as ZenPayroll, was established in 2011 as a cloud-based payroll, benefits, and human resource management software. The platform simplifies payroll and HR tasks for small businesses, and it streamlines administrative work by offering features like automated payroll processing, health insurance administration, and employee onboarding. Today, Gusto serves over 100,000 businesses across the United States.

QuickBooks Vs Gusto: Services Offered

QuickBooks provides a robust suite of offerings primarily focused on accounting and financial management. Its core features revolve around tracking income and expenses, capturing and organizing receipts, maximizing tax deductions, invoicing and payments, running detailed reports, and managing bills and accounts payable. Additionally, QuickBooks offers payroll services, but the depth and breadth of these features are secondary compared to its accounting services.

Gusto, on the other hand, primarily provides payroll, benefits, and HR services. These services include automated payroll, benefits administration, compliance support, HR resources, and tools, employee self-service, and time tracking, to name a few. While Gusto does allow for some level of accounting integration, its primary focus is on simplifying payroll and HR management for businesses.

Differentiating Features: QuickBooks and Gusto

QuickBooks shines in areas like invoicing, where users can customize, create, track, and send invoices in a matter of minutes. Its expense tracking feature exceeds Gusto, making it easier for businesses to track every dollar spent. Additionally, QuickBooks aids in taxes; it organizes income & expenses in one place, making it easy to file tax returns.

Gusto, however, stands out with its efficient payroll services which include direct deposit, paycheck printing, tax filing, and reporting. Payroll can be automated entirely, and employees can even access their paystubs online. Additionally, Gusto excels in managing employee benefits and workers compensation.

Comparing QuickBooks and Gusto for Business Needs

QuickBooks, known for its robust financial management capabilities, is a popular choice for businesses ranging from solo entrepreneurs and startups to medium-sized enterprises. Its emphasis on detailed financial tracking and reporting makes it an excellent fit for sectors such as non-profit organizations, professional services, retail, and others in need of comprehensive financial management.

On the other hand, Gusto positions itself as an extensive HR platform. It’s mainly targeted towards small and medium-sized businesses yearning to automate their HR and payroll processes. Gusto also offers solutions to improve benefits administration, ensuring compliance with federal and state laws, and streamlining various related tasks.

Both QuickBooks and Gusto offer valuable features tailored to different business needs. When deciding between the two, it would largely depend on what a business requires most. For thorough financial management, QuickBooks may be appropriate. In contrast, for businesses looking to automate HR and payroll, Gusto might be the perfect fit.

Detailed Review of QuickBooks

An Overview of QuickBooks

QuickBooks is a widespread accounting software solution that operates in a cloud-based environment. Developed by Intuit, a recognized software company known for creating tools aimed primarily at self-employed individuals and small to medium-sized businesses, QuickBooks is designed to centralize the management of sales, expenses, inventory, and payroll—all within a single system.

QuickBooks Features

One of the major features of QuickBooks is its easy-to-use dashboard that provides a clear overview of your business’s financial standing. It allows businesses to track income and expenses, accept business payments, create and send business invoices, run payroll, manage bills, generate reports, and track inventory. QuickBooks also syncs data across all your devices in real-time, enabling you always to have access to accurate information whether you’re on a desktop, laptop, or mobile device.

QuickBooks Pricing

QuickBooks’ pricing model is subscription-based, which means users can choose from different plans depending on their business needs. The plans range from the Simple Start plan, which is at $12.50 per month, to the Advanced plan at $90 per month. Each plan offers different features and levels of user access, enabling businesses to select the plan that best aligns with their needs and budget.

Ease of Use

One of the reasons QuickBooks is popular among small to mid-size businesses is because of its user-friendly interface. Even if you aren’t an accountant, QuickBooks is relatively easy to navigate and use. It’s intuitively designed and offers a step-by-step setup guide that takes you through the initial setup process to customize the platform to your specific needs.

Customer Service

Good customer support is crucial for any software product, and QuickBooks is no exception. QuickBooks provides multiple customer service channels, including phone support, live chat, email support, and an extensive online help center with articles, guides, and video tutorials. However, some users have noted long wait times to get in touch with a support representative.

QuickBooks Use cases

QuickBooks caters to various business types and offers features that can accommodate a diverse range of needs. Whether you’re running an online store, restaurant, nonprofit, or professional service business, QuickBooks can cater to your needs. For example, retailers and wholesalers can leverage QuickBooks to manage inventory, while professional service providers can track billable hours and invoice clients accordingly.

A Comparison: QuickBooks and Gusto

When looking at QuickBooks and Gusto, both platforms offer payroll services, but cater to different business needs due to their unique specialties. QuickBooks is essentially an accounting tool and does not harbor as many HR-related features as Gusto. However, it provides a comprehensive overview of a business’s financial health. Conversely, Gusto focuses more on payroll, benefits, and human resources, making it the tool of choice for businesses in need of extensive HR solutions. Therefore, the selection between the two will largely depend on your unique business requirements.

Detailed Review of Gusto

An In-Depth Look at Gusto

Gusto is a cloud-based system engineered to uncomplicate the intricate, yet crucial tasks of business operation. These tasks include everything from payroll management to benefits administration and creating HR solutions. Gusto has positioned itself as a tool that takes the administrative load off the shoulders of small to mid-sized businesses, letting them put their complete focus on business growth and strategic initiatives.

Among the many strengths of Gusto, one that stands out is its easy-to-use interface. Gusto boasts a design that is sleek, modern, and simple to navigate, unlike many other competitors. This user-friendly approach allows individuals with varying levels of technical ability to use Gusto with ease.

Cost and Pricing

Gusto follows a tiered pricing structure with different packages for various company needs. They offer a range of services from basic payroll processing to full-scale HR management. Depending on your business needs, the cost of Gusto can range from $45 per month to $161 per month, per employee. This flexibility makes Gusto a viable option for a broad spectrum of businesses.

Feature-Rich Functionality

Gusto’s feature-rich environment includes payroll, benefits, and HR tools. Its payroll service simplifies the payroll process, automatically calculating, paying, and filing federal, state, and local taxes. It also allows for unlimited payroll runs. Benefits administration takes care of health insurance, 401K, workers’ compensation, and more, and the HR platform helps manage everything from time tracking to onboarding, all within the same system.

Customer Support

Gusto is known for its exceptional customer support. Users often praise Gusto’s customer service for rapid responses, solution-oriented advice, and personable service. This strong support network ensures that users can quickly resolve any issues they encounter while using the software.

How Gusto Compares to QuickBooks

While QuickBooks is a stellar choice for accounting needs, Gusto arguably offers superior payroll and HR services. The key differentiating factor lies in their core strengths: QuickBooks prioritizes and excels in financial management whereas Gusto focuses on and excels in people management.

Beyond that, Gusto’s user experience is considered more intuitive and less complex than QuickBooks. As for pricing, both platforms have a range, but generally, Gusto has a more flexible price range depending on the various company needs.

Lastly, Gusto’s stellar customer support also sets it apart from QuickBooks.

Gusto in Practice

Consider the scenario of a budding tech startup, grappling with payroll management while expanding its team. When they decide to implement Gusto, they succeed in automating their payroll, guaranteeing precise operation and compliance with tax requirements. Additionally, they begin to offer their team benefits such as health insurance and 401K options directly via the platform. As a result, they can refocus on their area of expertise – innovation, doing away with the perturbation of payroll and benefits management.

Comparing QuickBooks and Gusto

QuickBooks and Gusto: A Comparison

Recognized as two impressive software options, QuickBooks and Gusto each present significant benefits based on individual user requirements. QuickBooks principally serves the needs of small to medium enterprises by offering extensive accounting functionalities, such as invoice generation, expense management, sales tracking and financial reporting.

On the other hand, Gusto is dedicated more closely to providing payroll, benefits, and HR services tailored for small businesses. It equips users with the ability to automate payroll, track time and attendance, offer health benefits, manage 401(k) plans, and consolidate HR tasks in one unified platform.

Key Features Comparison

QuickBooks and Gusto both offer unique features that distinguish them significantly in the market. QuickBooks provides tools to manage accounts receivable and payable, track income and expenses, reconcile bank accounts, run detailed reports, handle tax preparation, and provide a portal for clients to pay directly.

In contrast, Gusto offers services such as full-service payroll, which includes automatic tax filing, unlimited payrolls, multiple payroll schedules, and multi-state payroll. It also provides tools for HR management, like digital employee profiles, customizable offer letters, anonymous employee surveys, and compliance assistance.

Strengths and Weaknesses

QuickBooks stands out for its robust accounting features, as it allows users to keep all their financial data in one place, giving businesses the ability to track their financial health easily. It also fits into the needs of diverse businesses with its different plan options. However, the program’s complexity can make it a little challenging for newcomers to navigate.

On the other hand, Gusto shines for ease of use and employee self-service. The software is user-friendly and crucially includes services like compliance and benefits administration, which can be overwhelming for small businesses to handle independently. However, Gusto’s payroll features might be more than needed for businesses or freelancers whose needs revolve purely around accounting.

Potential Use Cases

The decision between QuickBooks and Gusto can depend largely on the specific needs of a business. For an organization requiring comprehensive accounting tools, QuickBooks might be the better choice. On the other hand, a business looking to manage payroll, benefits, and human resources more efficiently might find Gusto to be a better fit.

For example, a small business with several employees and a complex payroll schedule could benefit greatly from Gusto’s suite of payroll and HR tools. In contrast, a solo freelancer tracking expenses, income, and taxes might find more value in QuickBooks’ comprehensive accounting features. In some cases, businesses might find that a combination of both platforms best suits their needs.

Comparing QuickBooks and Gusto

When considering QuickBooks and Gusto, it’s evident that both platforms have unique advantages. QuickBooks excels with its comprehensive accounting tools, an essential asset for businesses concentrating on financial management. On the other hand, Gusto shines with full-service payroll and HR offerings, perfect for small businesses with intricate employment structures. Therefore, the ultimate choice between QuickBooks and Gusto relies on individual business requirements and demands.

Users’ experiences and reviews

User Experiences and Reviews: QuickBooks

Regarded as a reputable accounting software, QuickBooks receives accolades for its extensive capabilities, such as invoicing, expense tracking, and detail-oriented financial reporting. Users are satisfied with QuickBooks’ ability to simplify their accounting tasks and increase workflow efficiency.

However, some users find QuickBooks challenging initially, especially for those who lack basic accounting knowledge. Yet, they agree that after they get the hang of it, its diverse features make it worth the initial struggle. A common concern among users is the pricing of QuickBooks, which is relatively higher than some of its counterparts, potentially deterring small businesses with a limited budget.

Gusto User Experiences and Reviews

On the other hand, Gusto is a cloud-based platform designed with a focus on payroll, benefits, and human resource management. Gusto users highly appreciate its user-friendly interface and intuitive design, meaning one can start using the platform with minimal training. It’s frequently praised for simplifying the entire payroll process, making it a suitable choice for smaller businesses with no dedicated payroll department.

Despite its upsides, Gusto does have certain limitations that have been noted by users. The software does not offer extensive accounting features compared to QuickBooks, limiting its use to mainly payroll and HR management. Some users have also noted that Gusto’s customer service could use improvement.

Case Studies: QuickBooks vs Gusto

One case study highlights a small business owner who uses both QuickBooks and Gusto. The owner prefers QuickBooks for the business’s core accounting needs, finding the financial reporting capabilities essential for tracking profits and losses. On the other hand, Gusto excels in managing payroll and benefits for the business’s employees, making it preferred for HR-related tasks.

Another user who runs a tech startup pointed out the convenience of integrating Gusto with QuickBooks. They used Gusto for payroll and QuickBooks for bookkeeping. Not having to manually enter payroll information into their accounting software, as Gusto can automatically sync with QuickBooks, saved them considerable time and effort.

In conclusion, the choice between QuickBooks and Gusto largely comes down to your specific business needs.

QuickBooks is typically favored by businesses requiring sophisticated accounting tools, while Gusto leads the pack for those focusing on payroll and HR responsibilities. Testimonials suggest that many businesses find using both software in conjunction can provide a comprehensive solution to managing their finances and human resources.

After dissecting both QuickBooks and Gusto, it’s clear that each platform brings unique strengths to the table. Your decision on which to go with should hinge primarily on your business’s specific requirements. Be it the robustness of QuickBooks’ accounting functionalities or the simplicity and efficiency of Gusto’s payroll services, the choice should align with your business’s financial goals. Remember, a platform’s potential isn’t solely reliant on its features, but heavily depends on how these features interplay with your business operations, thus resulting in optimal financial management.