11 min read

QuickBooks vs Square: A Comprehensive Comparison


Content provided for general information. Talk to your advisor to learn about recent updates or other rules that may apply to your situation.

Disclosure: I may receive a referral fee if you buy software through the links on each page. However, most apps have free trials, so go ahead and try a few at no risk to you.

In today’s digital era, streamlined financial operations form an integral part of successful business management. With a myriad of financial management systems available, making the ideal pick can prove challenging. Among the dominant players in this sphere are QuickBooks and Square, each designed with unique attributes tailored to cater to varying business needs. This exploration delves into the intricacies of QuickBooks and Square, unfolding their unambiguous overviews, distinctive features, and pointing out their similarities and differences. Ultimately, this examination seeks to present balanced insights into these systems and further propose recommendations to allow potential users to navigate the selection process seamlessly.

Overview of QuickBooks and Square

Overview of QuickBooks and Square

QuickBooks and Square are two of the premier financial management tools used by businesses worldwide. The main features of these platforms are designed to simplify and streamline processes related to sales, finances, and customer relationship management.

QuickBooks, developed by Intuit, is primarily accounting software. It provides various features for managing sales and expenses, tracking daily transactions, and organizing financial records. QuickBooks comes in several variations, such as QuickBooks Online, QuickBooks Pro, and QuickBooks Enterprise, each designed to cater to different business sizes and needs. Noted for its user-friendly interface, QuickBooks also offers tools for managing and paying bills, generating reports, tax filing, invoice management, and payroll functions.

Square, on the other hand, started as a mobile credit card reader but has grown into a multifaceted financial solution. Along with processing payments, Square now provides products for point of sale (POS) tracking, invoice management, and online sales. Square’s ecosystem also includes solutions for appointment scheduling, employee management, and even a food delivery service. Furthermore, Square is renowned for its upfront pricing model and ease of use, making it a favorite among small business owners.

QuickBooks vs. Square: A Comparison

Although there is some overlap, QuickBooks and Square’s primary functions serve different facets of business finance. QuickBooks is primarily about managing, organizing, and interpreting financial data. It’s popular among business owners who need advanced bookkeeping and accounting features. The software offers comprehensive reports, tax assistance and has robust payroll support for businesses with employees.

In contrast, Square primarily focuses on sales transactions. It allows businesses to accept credit card payments using a mobile device, tracks sales, and provides simple financial reports. Additionally, Square tends to be more user-friendly for small businesses as it requires minimal setup and offers solutions that expand with the growth of the business. These include e-commerce integrations, marketing and loyalty programs, and payroll services.

Customer Relationship Management and Services

Both QuickBooks and Square offer features to improve and manage customer relationships. QuickBooks provides a Customer Resource Center where businesses can track customer details, contact information, and transaction history. The software also has features for invoice creation and delivery, payment reminders, and sales receipts—essential tools to manage customer relationships and ensure a smooth financial exchange.

Square also provides a customer directory to help businesses manage customer information. One of Square’s standout features is its marketing tools, which allow businesses to create, automate, and deliver email marketing campaigns. Additionally, Square’s loyalty program tools help businesses develop and manage customer loyalty programs, an essential feature for retaining customers and encouraging repeat business.

Choosing Between QuickBooks and Square: What’s Best For You?

A pivotal decision for any business choosing a financial management tool hinges upon the specific needs and size of the operation. QuickBooks typically serves as the go-to option for businesses seeking a comprehensive accounting solution, including nuanced features such as detailed reporting, handy tax assistance, and even payroll facilities.

Square, on the contrary, performs exceptionally well for businesses primarily dealing with sales transactions. If an easy-to-use interface for processing payments, sales tracking, and accessible financial reporting is what you’re looking for, Square fits the bill. Besides, its unique marketing tools and loyalty program services can significantly boost growth and customer retention efforts for small to medium-sized businesses.

In sum, before settling on QuickBooks or Square, it’s crucial for businesses to rigorously evaluate their requirements and needs. Both platforms offer invaluable but distinct services for seamlessly managing business finances and customer relations.

Features of QuickBooks

A Closer Look at QuickBooks: Features and Functionalities

Developed by Intuit, QuickBooks is widely favored among small to medium-sized businesses, along with independent entrepreneurs. Its reputation stems from offering complete financial transparency, furnished by its extensive features including expense monitoring, income management, invoice generation, diverse reporting options, and convenient payroll management.

Invoicing in QuickBooks

Invoicing in QuickBooks is efficient, customizable, and automated. You can quickly generate invoices, personalize them with a company logo, and send them directly to customers via email. This software offers invoice monitoring capabilities, allowing users to track and manage unpaid invoices, which can help improve cash flow and revenue management.

Expense Tracking in QuickBooks

An essential feature of QuickBooks is the ability to track sales, bills, and expenses holistically or categorize them specifically. You can also attach receipts, use your phone camera to take a snap of the receipt and upload it right into the system, linking the receipt to the particular expense. This feature aids in thorough record keeping and organization.

Reporting and Payroll Management in QuickBooks

Beyond invoicing and expense tracking, QuickBooks offers extensive reporting functionality. Reports such as Profit and Loss statements, Balance Sheet reports, or Customer reports are readily accessible and customizable. These drill-down reports will provide detailed insights that help inform strategic business decisions.

Payroll management is another area where QuickBooks shines. QuickBooks simplifies running payroll, calculating taxes, and filling out the necessary state and federal forms, making this less daunting for business owners. Notably, QuickBooks guarantees the accuracy of its payroll calculations, provided the data entered is correct.

Real-World Reviews for QuickBooks

On the whole, user reviews speak highly of QuickBooks. Many businesses and individual users praise its intuitive interface and comprehensive feature set. For instance, small business owners acknowledge the ease of use, timely updates, and robust reporting capabilities. On the downside, some users bemoan the steep learning curve and occasional glitches. Further, while customer support is generally rated as responsive, there are reports of slow turnaround time on more complex issues.

QuickBooks vs Square: Unveiling the Differences

QuickBooks and Square are notable for different reasons, each with their unique strengths. While both of them offer invoicing and expense tracking functionalities, QuickBooks presents these features at a more in-depth level.

Square is renowned for its point-of-sale system, and it delivers exceptionally in managing face-to-face transactions. However, QuickBooks holds sway with more solid accounting and reporting tools. Businesses with a brick-and-mortar presence or those involved in direct sales can find Square particularly beneficial.

In nutshell, Square stands out for sales and transaction management whereas QuickBooks is better tailored to businesses requiring sophisticated financial management tools due to its broader accounting solutions and comprehensive financial reporting.

Features of Square

The Point of Sale (POS) Excellence of Square

Square impresses with an all-inclusive point of sale (POS) system designed for businesses particularly in the retail and foodservice sectors. Adapted to streamline sales processes, its system enables businesses to process payments, apply discounts, determine taxes, oversee receipt management, and track sales history. With the addition of an offline mode, transactions can be handled seamlessly without dependence on an internet connection. This offers mobile businesses the flexibility they need in their transactions.

Payment Processing

Square’s efficiency in payment processing is another highlight of its functionality. Merchants can accept various forms of payment methods, including cash, credit, debit, and mobile payments such as Apple Pay and Google Pay. Their processing rates are competitive, generally offering flat rate pricing for various types of transactions. Square also provides a quick turnaround, with funds typically deposited as quick as the next business day. This ensures a straightforward transaction process without hindrance to cash flow.

Employee Management

In the Square system, employee management is as good as it gets, comes incorporated within the Square POS, allowing businesses to track employee hours, manage their roles and permissions, and integrate them into the Payroll service. This platform also has a team management dashboard, providing analytical data about sales by team members, which can help in performance evaluations and development.

Inventory Management

With Square, inventory management has never been easier. It automatically syncs to sales, reducing inventory counts and alerting when stock gets low. It also provides insights on product performance, enabling businesses to effectively plan their inventory according to sales trends. Moreover, it offers tools to manage thousands of items, bulk imports, exports, and printing labels.

Customer Feedback

Review of users indicates that Square’s seamless integration allows businesses to run efficiently, saving time and effort, particularly with its POS system’s ease of use and wide range of features. Businesses appreciate the flexibility offered by Square’s mobile POS system, which supports sales wherever customers are. The automated inventory management capability also earns high marks as it eliminates manual processes, provides automatic updates, and allows better inventory planning and control. The system’s robust analytics and reports also facilitate swift, data-informed decisions.

Comparison with QuickBooks

While Square excels as a POS and payment processing system, QuickBooks is renowned for its comprehensive accounting solutions. While Square does offer basic bookkeeping and reporting features, more extensive financial tracking and tax functions offered by QuickBooks are often necessary for larger businesses or those with more complex accounting needs. Also, QuickBooks integrates with a wider range of third-party apps.

When it comes to costs, Square’s payment processing fees are primarily per-transaction, while QuickBooks tends to charge monthly costs and transaction fees. Thus, the overall cost will depend on your business’s size, volume of transactions, and specific needs.


When looking at Square and QuickBooks, it can be observed that Square is a great fit for small and midsize businesses looking for a robust Point of Sale (POS) system that prioritizes simplicity, while QuickBooks is more appropriate for businesses which require comprehensive accounting solutions and intricate financial tracking.

Comparison between QuickBooks and Square

Comparing Square and QuickBooks: User-friendliness

Both QuickBooks and Square offer interfaces that are user-friendly, although the degree to which they are easy to use can be dependent on your specific needs. QuickBooks is renowned for its robust accounting features, providing a holistic tool for income, expense, tax, and more management. However, it is important to note that it may take new users some time to find their way around the platform due to its extensive functionalities.

Square, on the other hand, is principally a payment processing system, known for its simplicity and the ease with which it can be set up. Its interface is intuitive and straightforward to navigate, thereby making it a popular choice among small businesses and individual sellers. Although it may not offer as many detailed financial tracking features as QuickBooks, it might be more palatable to those new to digital business platforms.

QuickBooks vs Square: Features

QuickBooks provides rich features encompassing all aspects of business accounting. These include income and expense tracking, invoicing, payroll management, tax calculations, and budgeting. Additionally, it offers functionalities like inventory tracking for product-based businesses and project tracking for service-based businesses.

Square provides a solid set of features, heavily focused on transaction processing and customer management. It excels in seamless payment processing, invoicing, customer loyalty schemes, and basic inventory functions. However, when it comes to advanced accounting and financial management, it does not have as extensive features as QuickBooks.

QuickBooks vs Square: Pricing

Both QuickBooks and Square offer various pricing plans based on business needs. QuickBooks online plans start from $25/month for basic features to $150/month for advanced features. It also offers add-on services like payroll that can increase the cost. Square, on the other hand, charges transaction fees that start at 2.6% + 10 cents per tap, dip, or swipe for physical payments and slightly more for online sales, but there is no monthly subscription charge. This can make Square seem more affordable, especially for smaller businesses or individuals that handle fewer transactions.

QuickBooks vs Square: Customer Service

QuickBooks and Square have different strengths when it comes to customer service. QuickBooks offers extensive online support, including a big library of tutorials and a community forum. Telephone support is also available, making it easier to resolve complex issues.

Square also provides online resources but is often praised for its live chat support feature. It promises quicker response times and concise support to promptly solve any service issues. However, it doesn’t provide phone support unless you’re a member of a higher-cost plan.

QuickBooks vs Square: Customer Reviews

Both QuickBooks and Square have received positive reviews overall, but there are differences. QuickBooks is generally praised for its comprehensive features for accounting, but some users have noted that it can be overwhelming for beginners due to the breadth and complexity of its offerings.

Square generally receives positive feedback for its easy setup process and simplicity of use. On the downside, some users have mentioned occasional difficulties in transaction processing and lack of more comprehensive financial management tools.

Finding the Right Fit for Your Business

Medium to large-sized businesses, e-commerce platforms, and service-based industries such as legal services or consulting firms, often need robust accounting and financial features, making QuickBooks an ideal fit. It is specifically designed to cater to detailed financial management requirements, making it well-suited to these business types.

Conversely, Square is best suited for small businesses, individual sellers, or businesses that frequently engage in face-to-face transactions such as retail shops or food trucks. Its straightforward interface and transaction-centered functionalities make it a great choice for these businesses. Additionally, its mobile point-of-sale system can be a huge advantage for those who need to handle transactions on the go.


Comparing Features and Functionalities in QuickBooks vs. Square

Zip through your financial management tasks with QuickBooks, a versatile accounting software designed for small and medium businesses. Its array of functionalities—ranging from expense tracking, payroll management, and invoice creation to advanced features like inventory management, project profit tracking, and third-party app integration—provides you with comprehensive financial management tools.

In contrast, Square serves as a simple yet effective payment processing platform. Renowned for its easy-to-use interface and flat-rate transaction fees, it offers crucial features like point-of-sale solutions, invoice and payment processing, and basic inventory management. While Square does come with a range of business management tools, these may not be as extensive or as advanced as those provided by QuickBooks.

Cost Analysis: QuickBooks vs. Square

In terms of cost, Square offers a free plan with transaction-based pricing, which is ideal for businesses with variable sales volume. Additional features, like team management and loyalty programs, come with additional cost.

QuickBooks, however, operates on a subscription-based pricing model that scales with the size and needs of your business. It offers different packages that cater to self-employed individuals, small businesses, and enterprises. These packages vary in price and offer different levels of functionality, providing businesses with the flexibility to choose a solution that best suits their budget and needs.

Ease of Use

Both QuickBooks and Square are praised for their user-friendly interfaces. Square is particularly lauded for its intuitive point-of-sale system, while QuickBooks shines in its ability to simplify complex financial processes.

Though, users with little to no accounting experience might find QuickBooks a bit more challenging to navigate initially. On the other hand, Square’s simplicity and intuitive design make it easy for anyone to grasp, regardless of experience level.

Software Integration

QuickBooks offers integrations with a wide variety of third-party applications, which can expand its functionality and make it more applicable to a wider range of industries. Square also supports integration with some popular apps, but the range is not as extensive as that offered by QuickBooks.


Based on their unique features, QuickBooks is an excellent choice for businesses that require comprehensive accounting and financial management systems and can afford the higher cost. It is particularly useful for businesses that wish to automate their accounting processes, track inventory, manage payroll, and have access to detailed financial reports for decision making.

Meanwhile, Square would be a more suitable option for businesses with variable sales volume since its payment processing fees are transaction-based. Square is also a better choice for organizations that are seeking a simpler and more intuitive solution with a focus on ease of use, and those that are more focused on sales, invoicing, and payment processing rather than comprehensive accounting.

In summary, the decision between QuickBooks and Square should largely depend on the specific business needs, operational requirements, and budget.

After delving deep into the various aspects of both QuickBooks and Square, it’s evident that the choice between the two primarily hinges on individual business needs, budgets, and operations. Both pack a punch in terms of functionality, with QuickBooks excelling in in-depth financial reporting and Square shining in point-of-sale interactions. These systems each have their unique strengths for different business types. Therefore, the ultimate choice should resonate with the specific needs, budget, and scale of your business. This exploration hopes to equip you with the insights you need to select the tool that will propel your business to new heights of efficiency and success.